But don’t forget to line your eyes! Do so with this creamy, long-wearing, water-resistant pencil eyeliner in any one of 20 shades, coming in a range of finishes from matte to shimmer, and glitter to metallic. It’s a twist-up, so no need to sharpen, and you also get precision lining that’s smudge-resistant, too. Unless you want it smudged, of course, for the ultimate smoky eye.